- Auto Insurance
- /
- New York Auto Insurance
- /
- Auto Insurance in Suffolk County
- /
- Shelter Island Auto Insurance
Cheap Auto Insurance in Shelter Island, New York
Complete list of all auto insurance companies in Shelter Island, NY that provide cheap car insurance in Shelter Island. Get online quotes from best auto insurance providers in Shelter Island. Compare coverage options and prices.

Ameriprise
Ameriprise offers auto insurance in Shelter Island, NY. Ameriprise offers several coverage options such as liability coverage that provides protection, coverage for any injury that results an at-fault auto accident. There are different types of coverage that include collision and comprehensive coverages and other coverages. Examples include emergency road service. This car insurance company offers several convenience options that include easy claims system, student discounts, good driver discount and more.
Get a quote
Esurance
Esurance is an auto insurance company in Shelter Island, NY that provides many coverage options. Few of the options offered by Esurance include underinsured motorist damage coverage, pet injury protection, roadside assistance, collision and comprehensive coverage and medical payments coverage.
Get a quote
Kemper Direct
Kemper Direct is an affordable car insurance provider in Shelter Island, NY. Examples of the car insurance options provided by Kemper Direct include accident forgiveness, cheap premiums, uninsured motorist coverage, collision coverage and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.
Get a quote
National General
National General specializes in affordable car insurance in Shelter Island, NY. National General includes many coverage types, like collision coverage, Medical payments coverage, comprehensive coverage, accident forgiveness, new car replacement and more. National General is designed for Shelter Island residents who would like both a low-price auto insurance payment with sufficient coverage.
Get a quote
Geico
Geico provides cheap car insurance in Shelter Island, NY and is designed to provide an excellent choice for budget Shelter Island auto insurance shoppers. Geico is a good choice for people who are searching for insurance for a newly purchased car and those who consider a more affordable auto insurance.
Get a quote
Amica
Some of the best car insurance rates in Shelter Island, NY are offered by Amica. Dedicated service combined with several types of coverage along with extensive experience and sound advise help Amica to stand out from the competition. All standard forms of car insurance coverage such as liability, collision, comprehensive, medical payments that include rehabilitation and more.
Get a quote
Safeco
Safeco provides auto insurance in Shelter Island, NY. Safeco provides affordable automobile insurance rates and has many special auto coverages including: discount for electric cars, accident forgiveness, rental reimbursement, electronic billing, glass repair and mechanical breakdown insurance.
Get a quote
Hanover
Hanover provides car insurance in Shelter Island, NY. Hanover provides different types of coverage that include collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, liability coverage that offers bodily injury liability coverage as well as property damage liability coverage, medical payments coverage, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage that helps to cover expenses related to medical bills and car repairs if you are hit by a driver who doesn’t have car insurance, rental reimbursement coverage, personal injury protection, personal umbrella policy, property protection coverage and more.
Get a quote
State Farm
State Farm is an auto insurance provider in Shelter Island, NY that has dedicated agents to cover all insurance claims. Some of the benefits of working with State Farm include phone and online claim system, full payment discount, multiple policy discount, young driver discount and a transfer discount. Vehicle coverages include collision, comprehensive, towing and labor coverage, rental car expense, gap coverage and a dependable auto insurance package that combines comprehensive, collision and liability insurance for maximum protection.
Get a quote
Mercury
Mercury provides affordable car insurance coverage in Shelter Island, NY. Mercury offers repair of your covered car after an accident has occurred, or, if if your car was damaged beyond repair then a replacement car at zero cost other than your deductible. Mercury offers many coverage options such as liability, medical and vehicle coverages.
Get a quote
Allianz
Allianz is a car insurance company in Shelter Island, NY. Benefits include discount for anti-lock breaks, discounts for students, EZ pay discount, discounts for new car owners and much more. Allianz also offers affordable car insurance rates to Shelter Island, NY car owners. Coverage that helps to protect you and your car from uninsured drivers and hit-and-run accidents is available.
Get a quote
Foremost
Foremost provides auto insurance in Shelter Island, NY. Foremost offers sensible coverage options like liability coverage that includes protection, coverage for light or serious injury resulting from an at-fault auto accident. There are different types of coverage that offer comprehensive and collision coverage and other coverages. Examples include roadside services such as tire changes. This car insurance company offers various convenience options that include ability to file a claim both via phone and online, student discounts, good driver discount and more.
Get a quote
American National
American National is a car insurance company in Shelter Island, NY that specializes in many coverage options. Some of the options offered by American National include not insured motorist damage coverage, pet injury protection, roadside coverage, comprehensive and collision coverage and medical payments coverage.
Get a quote
Allied Insurance
Allied Insurance is a cheap auto insurance provider in Shelter Island, NY. Some of the car insurance options offered by Allied Insurance include accident forgiveness, affordable premiums, underinsured motorist coverage, collision coverage and emergency breakdown assistance.
Get a quoteAuto Insurance near Shelter Island, New York
- Auto Insurance in Nelliston, NY
- Auto Insurance in Yorkshire, NY
- Auto Insurance in Freeville, NY
- Auto Insurance in South Nyack, NY
- Auto Insurance in Tappan, NY
- Auto Insurance in Whitehall, NY
- Auto Insurance in Busti, NY
- Auto Insurance in Zena, NY
- Auto Insurance in Schroon Lake, NY
- Auto Insurance in Liverpool, NY
- Auto Insurance in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
- Auto Insurance in West Winfield, NY
- Auto Insurance in Lakewood, NY
- Auto Insurance in South Huntington, NY
- Auto Insurance in Kingston, NY
- Auto Insurance in Savona, NY
- Auto Insurance in Oakdale, NY
- Auto Insurance in Sodus, NY
- Auto Insurance in Maybrook, NY
- Auto Insurance in Lyon Mountain, NY
Find the best auto insurance rate in your area. 100% free service.